Taking notes from Mariah Carey on nailing an effortless makeup look

Kristofer Buckle is a legend when it comes to celebrity attractiveness. Over the course of his career, Buckle has glammed up a slew of celebrities, including Christina Aguilera, Blake Lively, Jennifer Lopez, Jessica Chastain, Katy Perry, and Blake Lively. He also has his own cosmetics brand, which includes must-haves like the new Cashmere Slip Lipstick in Disco, the Power Lock Setting Spray, and the Light Enhancing Duo—a highlighter palette he created for Christina Aguilera’s film Burlesque. NBD.

Longtime Mariah Carey’s fans have had the privilege of witnessing the renowned singer change over the previous three decades, just like anybody who has spent most of their life in the limelight. Carey’s style and attractiveness have grown as she aged and her profession reached new heights so that growth isn’t restricted to her artistic ability.

Carey has never been one to experiment with her appearance (her hair has been the same honey-blond hue for as long as we can recall), but her beauty selections have frequently adapted to the current trends of the day. Carey used to go to events with her hair in its natural curly form and minimum glitz in the early days of her career, but as the years have passed, she’s gone back and forth between straight and wavy styles, depending on the occasion.

Here’s Carey’s beauty evolution from the beginning of her career to now.